Ohhh... My Head... - Midwinter tastings '05

The best scoring beers during the darkest time of the year was Girardin Gueuze (White label), the filtered version of Girardin's gueuze. The breweries in 2nd and 3rd position are no surprises. Both Abbaye des Rocs and Dark Star has reputations as some of the world's best breweries.

We also had a sauna tasting, where beers from tropical coutries, and less flavourful beers from elsewhere were served in an environment that was more suited to them than Swedish winter. The result of this experiment was probably that bad beer does not better just because of heat, but the heat makes it easier to tolerate the bad taste... Not even sauna heat is however sufficient to tolerate crap such as Sofiero Guld.

Beers rated Jan-Feb 2005

POS

BEER

COUNTRY

SCORE

JZ

PS

LS

FH

OH

JB

BA

HL

ABV

STYLE

117

Girardin Gueuze (White label)

Belgium

4,39

 

4

5

 

5

 

4-

 

5,0%

Gueuze/Lambic

160

Abbaye des Rocs La Nounnette

Belgium

4,32

 

5-

5-

 

4+

 

3+

 

7,5%

Ale, Belgian style

208

Dark Star Critical Mass, cask

England

4,26

 

5-

 

 

 

 

 

 

7,0%

Ale, British style

294

Nynäshamns Oliver Oatmeal Stout, cask

Sweden

4,22

 

5-

5-

3+

 

4-

 

4+

4,0%

Porter/Stout

358

Durham Decade

England

4,15

 

4+

4+

4

 

 

 

 

10,0%

Ale, British style

420

L'Atrébate Blond

France

4,10

 

4+

4+

 

4-

 

4

 

6,0%

Ale, Belgian style

844

Durham St. Cuthbert

England

3,89

 

4-

4

4+

 

 

 

 

6,5%

Ale, British style

887

L'Atrébate Brune

France

3,87

 

4-

4

 

4+

 

4-

 

7,0%

Ale, Belgian style

947

Urchon Brune

Belgium

3,85

 

4-

4-

 

4+

 

4

 

7,0%

Ale, Belgian style

1043

Durham Cloister

England

3,80

 

4-

4

4

 

 

 

 

4,5%

Ale, British style

1138

Zwijntje

Belgium

3,76

 

4-

4+

 

4

 

3

 

8,0%

Ale, Belgian style

1167

Dark Star City Porter, cask

England

3,75

 

4

 

 

 

 

 

 

5,5%

Porter/Stout

1167

Adnams Tally Ho, cask

England

3,75

 

4

 

 

 

 

 

 

7,0%

Ale, British style

1167

Helsinge Rököl, draught

Sweden

3,75

 

4

 

 

 

 

 

 

5,0%

Special

1450

L'Atrébate Bière de Printemps

France

3,70

 

4

4

 

3+

 

3+

 

6,0%

Ale, Belgian style

1456

L'Atrébate Ambrée

France

3,70

 

4-

4-

 

4-

 

4

 

6,0%

Ale, Belgian style

1489

De Graal Blond

Belgium

3,69

4-

4-

 

 

 

4-

3+

4

6,5%

Ale, Belgian style

1579

Durham Benedictus

England

3,64

 

4

4-

3+

 

 

 

 

8,4%

Ale, British style

1671

Gensch Mannekes Pies

Belgium

3,60

 

4+

4+

 

3+

 

2-

 

5,0%

Wheat beer

2191

Durham White Magic

England

3,48

 

3+

3+

4

 

 

 

 

7,0%

Ale, British style

2354

Arcobräu Weissbier Dunkel

Germany

3,42

 

3+

4

 

3+

 

3

 

5,3%

Wheat beer

2383

Arcobräu Weissbier Hell

Germany

3,41

 

4-

4-

 

4

 

2

 

5,3%

Wheat beer

2816

De Proef BioBen

Belgium

3,26

 

3+

3

 

4+

 

2+

 

6,5%

Ale, Belgian style

2869

Adnams Fisherman, cask

England

3,24

 

3+

 

 

 

 

 

 

4,5%

Ale, British style

3167

Durham Evensong

England

3,23

 

3-

3+

4

 

 

 

 

5,0%

Ale, British style

3191

Blitzkrieg Bock

Germany

3,22

3+

4

 

 

 

3+

2+

2

6,5%

Lager, Bock

3573

Bartram's Xmas Holly Daze

England

3,08

 

3

4-

 

3

 

3-

 

5,0%

Ale, British style

3630

Hepworth Christmas Ale

England

3,06

 

3

2+

 

3+

 

4

 

7,5%

Ale, British style

3632

Leroy Peter Benoit

Belgium

3,06

 

3

3+

 

3

 

3

 

5,0%

Ale, Belgian style

3716

St. Peter's Lemon & Ginger

England

3,03

 

2+

4-

 

3-

 

4

 

4,7%

Special

3852

Hair of the Dog Ruth

USA

2,98

 

3

 

 

 

 

 

 

5,6%

Ale, Belgian style

3852

Bath SPA, cask

England

2,98

 

3

 

 

 

 

 

 

3,7%

Ale, British style

4278

Baltika 4 Originalnoe Temnoe Pivo

Russia

2,90

3+

3+

 

 

 

3

2+

2-

5,6%

Lager, Dark

4643

Bath Gem, cask

England

2,73

 

3-

 

 

 

 

 

 

4,1%

Ale, British style

4809

Ostravar Premium

Czech Rep.

2,72

 

3

3-

 

3+

 

2-

 

5,0%

Lager, Light

4890

Belle-Vue Kriek Extra

Belgium

2,68

1-

3

 

 

 

3

4-

4

4,3%

Gueuze/Lambic

4981

Wychwood Duchy Originals Organic Ale

England

2,64

 

2

3

 

3

 

3

 

5,0%

Ale, British style

5022

Leroy Paulus

Belgium

2,62

 

3-

3-

 

2

 

3+

 

6,0%

Ale, Belgian style

5205

Danish Royal Stout

Malaysia

2,51

3+

2+

 

 

 

3

2

2-

8,0%

Porter/Stout

5248

Maasland Witte Wieven Witbier

Netherlands

2,49

2

3

 

 

 

3

1

3+

5,5%

Wheat beer

5287

Guinness Draught 3.5%

Ireland

2,47

 

2+

 

 

 

 

 

 

3,5%

Porter/Stout

5510

Halve Maan Zeeuwsche Witte

Netherlands

2,41

2-

3

 

 

 

2+

2

3

5,0%

Wheat beer

5702

Broughton Waitrose Organic Ale

Scotland

2,30

 

3-

3-

 

2-

 

2

 

4,6%

Ale, British style

5706

Greene King The Beer To Dine For

England

2,30

 

2+

2+

 

2

 

3-

 

5,0%

Ale, British style

5815

Loddon Ferrymans Gold, cask

England

2,21

 

2

 

 

 

 

 

 

4,4%

Ale, British style

5965

Zwerger Bräu Pilsener

Germany

2,16

3

2

 

 

 

2

2

2-

4,9%

Lager, Light

5970

Van Pur Barley Strong

Poland

2,16

3

2-

 

 

 

2+

2+

2-

6,6%

Lager, Bock

6001

Budweiser Budvar Super Strong

Czech Rep.

2,13

 

2

2-

 

2

 

3+

 

7,6%

Lager, Bock

6077

Falcon Pilz

Sweden

2,08

3-

3-

 

 

 

1

1+

2

5,0%

Lager, Light

6094

Baron's Strong Brew (Malaysia)

Malaysia

2,07

3

1-

 

 

 

2+

2+

3+

8,8%

Lager, Bock

6103

Borsodi Bivaly Sör

Hungary

2,06

2

2+

 

 

 

1+

2

3-

6,5%

Lager, Bock

6144

Fuglsang Birdie

Denmark

2,03

 

2-

2-

 

2+

 

3

 

3,4%

Special

6165

Borsodi Borostyán

Hungary

2,01

2+

2+

 

 

 

2-

2

1+

5,2%

Lager, Dark

6177

Bangla Premium Beer

England

1,99

 

1+

2-

 

3-

 

3

 

5,5%

Lager, Light

6211

Sea Dog Raspberry Wheat Ale

USA

1,97

2-

2-

 

 

 

2-

3-

3

4,7%

Special

6225

Castel (Ethiopia)

Ethiopia

1,96

 

2-

 

 

 

 

 

 

4,8%

Lager, Light

6384

Van Pur Karpackie Pils

Poland

1,89

2+

2-

 

 

 

2-

2+

2-

4,0%

Lager, Light

6417

Sea Dog Wild Blueberry Wheat Ale

USA

1,86

2-

1+

 

 

 

1+

3

3

4,7%

Special

6442

Carlsberg Special Brew (Malaysia)

Malaysia

1,83

2+

2-

 

 

 

2-

1+

2+

8,8%

Lager, Bock

6483

Asahi Dry (Thailand)

Thailand

1,78

2

1+

 

 

 

2

1

3+

5,0%

Lager, Light

6492

Chernigivske Taller

Ukraine

1,77

2+

1+

 

 

 

1+

2+

2

4,7%

Lager, Light

6541

Leroy Sasbräu

Belgium

1,71

 

1+

2

 

3-

 

1

 

6,3%

Lager, Light

6631

Martens Pils

Belgium

1,68

2-

1+

 

 

 

2+

3-

1

5,0%

Lager, Light

6666

De Troch Chapeau Faro

Belgium

1,63

 

1+

1

 

2+

 

2+

 

4,8%

Gueuze/Lambic

6667

Mongozo Palmnut

Belgium

1,63

 

1+

2

 

2

 

1+

 

7,0%

Special

6678

San Miguel Gold Falcon

Phillipines

1,60

2-

1

 

 

 

2

2

2+

5,0%

Lager, Light

6786

Obolon Hike Premium

Ukraine

1,47

2-

1+

 

 

 

2-

2+

1-

5,0%

Lager, Light

6805

St. George Beer

Ethiopia

1,45

 

1

 

 

 

 

 

 

4,5%

Lager, Light

6852

Obolon Magnat

Ukraine

1,43

2

1

 

 

 

1

2+

1+

5,3%

Lager, Light

6878

Königsberg Lager Bier

Russia

1,38

2

1+

 

 

 

1+

1

1+

4,5%

Lager, Light

6911

Astra Pilsener

Germany

1,31

2+

1

 

 

 

1

2-

1-

4,9%

Lager, Light

6923

Krüger Export Beer

Belgium

1,29

 

1

2-

 

2-

 

1

 

4,8%

Lager, Light

7043

King Lion Export

Sweden

1,10

2+

1-

 

 

 

1

1

1-

5,0%

Lager, Light

7045

Badger Fursty Ferret

England

1,09

 

0+

1+

 

1+

 

2

 

4,4%

Ale, British style

7064

Sofiero Guld

Sweden

1,03

2+

0

 

 

 

2-

1-

1+

7,5%

Lager, Bock

7155

Fink Bräu Pils

Germany

0,60

 

1-

1

 

1-

 

0

 

2,1%

Lager, Light

Rated by: Johan Zetterlund, Per Samuelsson, Lars Samuelsson, Fredrik Huldt, Oscar Hansson, Jonas Bofjäll, Björn Alnebo and Helena Lindh

To the News page

Updated 2005-05-18 Per Samuelsson